On Churches and Mosques

I have spent the last four months at the cusp of the division between East and West, between Islam and Christianity. Nowhere can this be seen better than in Cyprus.

In Famamagusta, or Gazimagusa as it is known in Turkish, I see the 14th century twin churches of the Templars and the Hospitallers, the Nestorian Church, the ruins of St Francis, St George of the Latins and other churches, all showing the enormous wealth of the Byzantine and Venetian republics. In all, 365 churches were built inside the old city walls. As in Istanbul, when the Ottomans took Cyprus, they converted churches to mosques. The 14th century St Nicolas Cathedral is now Lala Mustafa Pasha Mosque.

In Islam there is a kind of logic to convert churches to mosques as the Quran is the final complete revelation and testament of God, given to the Prophet Muhammad. Thus the incomplete Christianity is superseded, and the minaret “completes” the church.

Although Northern Cyprus does not seem particularly religious – few women cover their heads, and those that do are mostly from the Turkish mainland; alcohol is on sale in every cafe and shop; and there are no crowds outside mosques – it was religion, or rather the desecration of Greek orthodox churches that is one of the points that still fuels hatred. “Enjoy yourself in the land of racial purity and true apartheid. Enjoy the sight of our desecrated churches” is one of the signs that welcomes those crossing over the border from Greek Cyprus.

I drive up to St Hilarion Castle, built by the Byzantines between the 7th and 14th centuries at the highest point in the mountains as protection against the Arabs, and then through the olive groves towards the village of Kazanköy. It is late afternoon, and the goatherds are coming out into the hills to collect their charges. I stop at the Greek cemetery. The marble crosses are all broken, and most are piled up in a heap. I make out their names: Vasilidis, Stefanou, Karagounis;  died 1972, dıed 1970, died 1969. Nothing after August 1974 of course. I drive on into the village. Overripe lemons are dropping off the lemon trees along the road. The village looks wealthy. Lots of cars, extra storeys built onto houses. In the square the small church has now become a mosque. A bust of Atatürk, as in every village in Turkish Cyprus, adorns the square, next to the Spor Külübü. Pointing to one of the great ironies: portraits of the human form, sculpture more than any other form, are strictly forbidden by the Quran.

The scars run deep in this divided island. What happened to the Greek villagers? Many went to Southern Cyprus; others emıgrated to the mainland, the US or Australia; others dısappeared. Almost certainly kılled. As did many Turkish Cypriots: “Armed Greek Cypriots came to our villages with policemen on 14th August 1974, and took all the men of the village away … Suddenly the man at the bottom of the retaining wall shot one round. This was a sıgnal. They started shooting like crazy. I was slightly ınjured in my side, and I fell to the ground. A friend of mine’s corpse fell on top of me. I stayed where I was wıthout moving” (Trapped in the Green Line, Tony Angastiniotis, Rustem, Lefkosha).

The story has been repeated many times in Belfast, Beirut, Bosnia and many many other places…

3 Responses to “On Churches and Mosques”

  1. Saulo Alencastre Says:

    Can you give a brief explanation on these city shootings? =)

  2. Suzete Dilger Says:

    It’s hard to believe that centuries old religious hatred is still kept alive, and is still the cause of so many unnecessary deaths and destruction in certain parts of the world…

    “the more things change, the more they stay the same…”

  3. jmilton6000 Says:

    Saulo:

    The shootings were probably carried out by EOKA, the Greek illegal paramilitary force, which wanted the cleanse Cyprus of Turks and join it to Greece – this was called Enosis. They were active from independence from Britain in 1960, but when their leader, Nikos Sampson, was made President of Cyprus after Archbishop Makarios was deposed following the military coup in 1974, Turkey feared a wholescale massacre of Turkish Cypriots and invaded the island, putting the northern part of the island under Turkish control and forcibily moving the Greeks out of villages such as the one I visited. There is a link to a map of Cyprus after the last blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: